Coverage Comparison
US President Donald Trump has said he would like the United States to take control of Iran's oil, according to interviews and comments reported by multiple outlets. In an interview with the Financial Times published on Sunday, Trump stated that his "preference would be to take the oil" and added, "To be honest with you, my favorite thing is to take the oil in Iran but some stupid people back in the US say: 'why are you doing that?' But they're stupid people." This was reported by both The Guardian and TASS, though The Guardian provided additional context and analysis.
Earlier, at a Cabinet meeting on March 26, Trump said that taking control of Iranian oil was "an option," as reported by TASS.
Key Claims
The central claim is that Trump wants US forces to seize Kharg Island, a five-mile strip through which about 90% of Iran's oil is exported, according to The Guardian. The Guardian also reports that Iran has effectively blocked the Strait of Hormuz to most commercial traffic following the outbreak of war in late February. These claims are not independently verified by other sources in the provided coverage.
The Guardian quotes experts who criticize Trump's statement as a disregard for international law. Patrick Bigger, co-director of the Transition Security Project, called it "a real 'might-makes-right' logic that is both abhorrent and spectacularly miscalculated." Amir Handjani, an energy lawyer and resident fellow at the Quincy Institute, said the statement "completely discredited" Trump's war on Iran. These expert opinions are only reported by The Guardian, and TASS does not include them.
Perspectives
The Guardian's coverage frames Trump's remarks as part of a broader pattern of "fossil-fuel imperialism," emphasizing the potential illegality and strategic miscalculation. The article also notes that on Monday Trump threatened to "blow up and completely obliterate" Iran's energy infrastructure if the Strait of Hormuz is not reopened and a peace deal is not reached shortly. It mentions that Iran attacked a fully loaded crude oil tanker at Dubai port on Monday, and that the conflict has killed thousands of people and disrupted global energy supplies.
TASS's coverage is neutral and focuses solely on Trump's statements, providing direct quotes without additional analysis or context. This reflects the agency's role as a Russian state news outlet, often relaying official statements without editorializing.
The conflict, which began in late February, has already caused significant casualties and energy market disruptions, according to The Guardian. Trump is due to provide an update on the war on Wednesday, and on Tuesday he said the conflict could end within weeks, leading to a stock market surge. Iran, however, has said it would need guarantees against future attacks to halt its counteroffensive.
As the situation develops, the international community watches closely, with experts warning that any attempt to seize Iranian oil would likely escalate tensions further and violate established norms of international law.