Starmer faces leadership challenge after Labour's local election losses

Lead

UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer is facing a leadership challenge following the Labour Party's heavy losses in local elections, with a backbench MP saying she will stand for the leadership if no senior figure steps forward.

Catherine West, a former Foreign Office minister, said she would put her name forward on Monday morning if no other leadership hopefuls emerged. "If ... there are no leadership hopefuls who come forward tomorrow, then Monday morning I will put my name forward to stand for the leader of the Labour Party," she told BBC Radio, as reported by ABC Australia and the South China Morning Post.

Starmer's position has been under mounting pressure since Labour recorded its worst local election results for a governing party since 1995, according to ABC Australia and the South China Morning Post. More than 20 lawmakers have publicly and privately called on him to set out a timetable for his departure, these outlets reported.

Coverage comparison

Reporting on the crisis has varied in emphasis. ABC Australia, Al Jazeera and the South China Morning Post have each framed the story around the challenge from West and the scale of the election losses. Al Jazeera's coverage also noted that more than 30 Labour MPs have called for Starmer to resign or set a timetable, and highlighted the party's loss of almost 1,500 councillors in England, the departure of First Minister Eluned Morgan in Wales, and a second-place finish in Scotland.

The Guardian has published several pieces examining the mechanics of any leadership change, the Labour rulebook, and the potential contenders. One article explained that a leadership contest requires the endorsement of 81 Labour MPs, a rule that makes it difficult to unseat a sitting leader. Another focused on the roles of potential candidates Andy Burnham, Wes Streeting and Angela Rayner, noting that Streeting has denied plans to challenge Starmer.

Given the different angles, the picture that emerges is of a party in turmoil, with no clear consensus on how — or whether — Starmer's departure might occur.

Key claims

• Catherine West's challenge: The backbencher, who was sacked as a Foreign Office minister last year, said she would launch a leadership bid if no cabinet minister came forward by Monday morning. Multiple outlets, including ABC Australia, Al Jazeera and The Guardian, reported this.
• Election losses: Labour suffered its worst local election performance for a governing party since 1995, according to ABC Australia and the South China Morning Post. Al Jazeera reported that Labour lost almost 1,500 councillors in England, mostly to Reform UK and the Greens, and lost power in Wales after 27 years.
• Leadership challenge rules: The Labour rulebook requires a challenger to secure the written support of 20% of the parliamentary party, currently 81 MPs, to trigger a contest. The Guardian reported that West's support was well below that threshold — Al Jazeera quoted her saying she had the backing of 10 MPs so far. Starmer has promised to stand again if a contest is forced, The Guardian reported.
• Potential candidates: Andy Burnham, the Greater Manchester mayor, is considered a potential candidate, though his route back to parliament is complicated by the need to win a byelection. Wes Streeting, who resigned as health secretary, has denied plans to challenge Starmer. Angela Rayner, Starmer's former deputy, is also reported to be considering a bid, according to The Guardian.
• Starmer's advisers: In an effort to shore up his position, Starmer named former prime minister Gordon Brown and former deputy Labour leader Harriet Harman as advisers, as reported by ABC Australia and the South China Morning Post.
• Government response: Justice Secretary David Lammy, a close Starmer ally, said there would be "no timetable for departure" and urged Labour to move on from the "spectacular own goal" of leadership speculation, The Guardian reported.

Perspectives

Starmer's allies: Led by David Lammy, the prime minister's supporters insist he will not set a departure timetable and remain focused on governing. Lammy described Starmer as resilient and stressed that there is no contest under way.

Starmer's critics: A growing number of Labour MPs, including Catherine West and Clive Betts, are calling for a change in leadership, arguing that the party needs a clear plan to move forward. They cite the scale of the election losses as evidence that Starmer's leadership is no longer viable.

Leadership contenders: Andy Burnham and Angela Rayner are both considering bids, while Wes Streeting has denied any intention of challenging. Burnham's path to Westminster is complicated by the need to win the Makerfield byelection, where the sitting MP Josh Simons has stepped down to allow him to run.

The party's broader concerns: Some Labour MPs worry that replacing Starmer could be seen as self-serving during a cost of living crisis, and that no clear alternative may prove to be an improvement, The Guardian reported. This caution tempers the push for change.