Lead
A widespread Telstra outage on Wednesday disrupted phone and internet services across Australia, leaving small businesses and individuals counting the cost. Building designer Belinda Stewart, who runs a practice in regional Victoria, described the day as debilitating, unable to text clients or receive calls for several hours. Uber driver Turab Ali, who has been driving full-time for about a month, lost up to $400 in expected earnings — a significant sum given his 12-hour, six-day work week.
The outage, which Telstra attributed to a software bug that caused the network's clocks to go out of sync, has raised questions about compensation under Australian Consumer Law and the broader economic impact, which an expert says could reach hundreds of millions of dollars.
Coverage comparison
ABC Australia, the public broadcaster, carried both personal accounts and expert analysis of the outage. One report focused on the experiences of small business owners, including Stewart, who noted that in regional areas like Bairnsdale, Victoria, customers are often reliant on Telstra's network because of its broader coverage. Another report highlighted the plight of an Uber driver and included commentary on legal rights from a law professor and advocacy groups.
Both accounts attributed the outage to a software bug that caused the network's clocks to go out of sync, a detail that was consistent across the reporting.
Key claims
- Outage timing and cause: The outage occurred on Wednesday and affected both phone calls and internet services. Telstra attributed the failure to a software bug that caused the network's clocks to go out of sync.
- Impact on individuals: Small businesses, including a building designer and a nursery owner, were affected. Uber driver Turab Ali lost up to $400 in expected earnings, and said he had four trips cancelled during what would have been a busy morning shift.
- Economic cost: RMIT associate professor Mark Gregory estimated the economic cost could run into hundreds of millions of dollars. He cited an average cost of $4,000 to $5,000 per hour for small to medium businesses, with some, like cafes, losing $20,000 or more during a four- or five-hour outage.
- Compensation considerations: Telstra is considering compensation for affected customers. Ali has moved his second service to Optus and intends to seek compensation, while Stewart said she will not ask for compensation but predicts Telstra will face pressure.
- Legal rights: Under Australian Consumer Law, services costing less than $100,000 are generally covered by consumer guarantees, including the requirement to provide services with due care and skill. University of Melbourne law professor Jeannie Paterson said the key question is whether Telstra was negligent in failing to take reasonable steps against a foreseeable risk. If negligence is proven, customers may recover the cost of the service during the period of unavailability.
Perspectives
Small business owners: Belinda Stewart, a building designer from Bairnsdale, said the outage left her "in the dark" for hours, unable to text clients or receive calls. She won't be seeking compensation but predicts others will.
Rideshare driver: Tura Ali, an Uber driver, lost up to $400 in expected earnings. He has moved his second service to another provider and plans to seek compensation, saying Telstra should repay customers for losses incurred.
Telecommunications and law experts: Mark Gregory from RMIT provided cost estimates, while law professor Jeannie Paterson outlined the legal framework, noting that compensation depends on whether Telstra was negligent. The Australian Communications Consumer Action Network (ACCAN) and the Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry also commented on customers' rights.
Telstra: The company is considering compensation for affected customers, acknowledging the disruption caused by the outage, which was triggered by a software bug.