Lead
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, acting on the recommendation of security officials, has instructed the Shin Bet (Israel Security Agency) to investigate the alleged leak of the start date of Operation Roaring Lion to an unnamed media outlet. The decision, reported by the Jerusalem Post, follows a cabinet meeting in which Shin Bet chief David Zini outlined the challenges of such a probe.
Coverage Comparison
The Jerusalem Post reported that during the cabinet meeting, Zini clarified that the matter could be investigated, but it would be difficult because so many people were privy to the secret, adding that the chances of uncovering the truth were low. After the meeting, Netanyahu issued another directive to investigate the matter and present the findings to him. Following an internal review by the Shin Bet, the agency's legal advisers determined that Netanyahu's directive required the opening of an investigation.
The investigation has since become a point of political contention. The Jerusalem Post detailed that Channel 14 commentator Yaakov Bardugo revealed on Galei Israel radio that he had met with Zini at Shin Bet headquarters to discuss the leak investigation. Bardugo described himself as "a media personality" rather than a journalist, which drew sharp criticism from the Yashar party, led by Gadi Eisenkot, and the Movement for Quality Government in Israel.
Key Claims
- Netanyahu instructed the Shin Bet to investigate the alleged leak of the start date of Operation Roaring Lion, as reported by the Jerusalem Post.
- During a cabinet meeting, Shin Bet chief David Zini said the matter could be investigated but noted the difficulty due to the number of people privy to the secret, with low chances of uncovering the truth.
- The investigation could be based on Netanyahu's directive and the powers granted to the intelligence agency, without needing attorney-general approval since journalists would not be questioned.
- US officials are outraged over the reported intel leak.
- The Defense Security Authority recommended that the leak be investigated.
- Channel 14 commentator Yaakov Bardugo met with Zini to discuss the leak investigation, a claim that originated from Bardugo's own revelation on radio and was reported by the Jerusalem Post.
- The Yashar party issued a statement criticizing Zini's meeting with Bardugo, questioning why Zini discussed the matter with someone who is not a journalist and has a clear political agenda.
- The Movement for Quality Government in Israel demanded full disclosure of the reported meeting between Zini and Bardugo.
Perspectives
Netanyahu's Directive
The prime minister's directive to investigate the leak is framed as a response to security officials' recommendations, aiming to uncover the source of the breach within the defense establishment.
Shin Bet Chief's Position
David Zini acknowledged the investigation's difficulty and low chances of success, but proceeded under the legal authority granted by the prime minister's directive.
Yashar Party
The party, led by Gadi Eisenkot, criticized Zini's meeting with Bardugo, calling it a "grave incident" and demanding an explanation for why the Shin Bet chief discussed the matter with a media figure with a political agenda.
Movement for Quality Government in Israel
The civil society group demanded full disclosure of the reported meeting between Zini and Bardugo, raising concerns about political influence over security decisions.