Lead

The Israeli government is expected to approve a plan to divert approximately NIS 568 million from a five-year plan for developing Arab society to fund Shin Bet (Israel Security Agency) activity and police operations against organized crime. The proposal, set for discussion at a cabinet meeting, has sparked debate over the government's priorities toward Arab society.

According to a statement from Cabinet Secretary Yossi Fuchs, the combined budget for the Shin Bet and police will amount to about NIS 567 million. The funds are to be taken from government decision 550, approved in 2021 to reduce economic and social gaps between Arab society and the rest of the population. That plan includes budgets for employment, vocational training, education, transportation, infrastructure, industrial zones, and strengthening local authorities.

Coverage Comparison

Reports on the proposal have emphasized different aspects. One report, published on July 6, announced that the Shin Bet would receive a dedicated budget of half a billion shekels to address Arab crime, with funding sourced from several government ministries through a reallocation from Resolution 550. That report framed the move as a positive development, quoting National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir praising the decision.

Another report, published on July 14, focused on the broader implications, noting that the proposal would signal a shift in government priorities toward Arab society, directing resources from economic development to enforcement and intelligence. This report also highlighted opposition from the Mossawa Center for the Rights of Arab Citizens, which appealed to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Attorney-General Gali Baharav-Miara to stop the move.

A third report, published on July 16, confirmed that the government approved a plan to allocate approximately NIS 497 million toward integrating Shin Bet agents into the Israeli Police, with specific allocations for a Shin Bet unit targeting illegal weapons smuggling and a police unit for Arab-sector crime.

The numbers have varied across reports: while the total budget has been described as NIS 567 million, the approved allocation is reported as approximately NIS 497 million, with the diverted sum from the five-year plan at about NIS 568 million. The proposal under discussion is smaller than earlier figures, which ranged from NIS 1 billion to NIS 1.3 billion, and an internal document examined diverting up to NIS 1.4 billion.

Key Claims

  • The plan was spearheaded by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, Equality Minister May Golan, and National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir, as reported by Jerusalem Post.
  • About NIS 364.5 million will be allocated to the Shin Bet to establish a specialized unit to target illegal weapons smuggling and bolster intelligence capabilities, according to Jerusalem Post.
  • Approximately NIS 132.4 million will go to the Israel Police to establish a dedicated unit for Arab-sector crime, as reported by Jerusalem Post.
  • The Shin Bet was allocated an additional NIS 35 million to hire 130 personnel, according to Jerusalem Post.
  • The budget is to be taken from government decision 550, approved in 2021, as stated in multiple reports.
  • The Mossawa Center has demanded the move be stopped and is considering legal action if the proposal is approved, as reported by Jerusalem Post.

Perspectives

The Israeli government, through the Prime Minister's Office and Cabinet Secretary, supports the plan as a necessary measure to combat crime in Arab society, which has been described as a "national plague." National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir called the decision "tremendous news for the citizens of Israel, bitter news for the crime organizations," and credited the new Shin Bet chief, David Zini, for mobilizing for the cause.

The Mossawa Center for the Rights of Arab Citizens opposes the proposal, arguing that it diverts funds intended to address social and economic conditions that underlie crime. In an urgent letter to Netanyahu and the Attorney-General, the center demanded the move be stopped and threatened legal action, saying the proposal would shift priorities from development to enforcement.