Lead

The Pentagon's official online list of service members killed in the ongoing Iran war does not include the four soldiers who died during renewed fighting over the weekend, despite the fact that their names were included in a Pentagon press release on the formal transfer of their remains back to the United States on Wednesday. The discrepancy has drawn attention to the human toll of the conflict, even as President Donald Trump prepares to attend a ceremony honoring the fallen.

Coverage comparison

Reporting on the casualty list varies in focus and detail. The Guardian highlighted the exclusion of the four recent deaths from the Pentagon's list, noting that the number of US military personnel killed during Operation Epic Fury remains at 14 on the Defense Casualty Analysis System website, despite being last updated on Wednesday. The Guardian also reported that a separate "Names of Fallen" list on the same site currently includes just 13 service members.

According to a New York Times report referenced by the Guardian, the Pentagon website listed 18 American service members as killed on Wednesday, but was changed on Thursday to exclude three service members killed last Friday, Saturday and Sunday, as Iran retaliated for new US strikes with an attack on a base used by US forces in Jordan. The list also excluded a fourth soldier killed during a controlled detonation of an Iranian drone at Erbil air base in Iraq.

Three military officials told the Times that "one reason behind the change was that the Trump administration decided to remove four service members killed this past weekend from the list … because their deaths occurred after President Trump declared a cease-fire in the war in April." A Pentagon spokesperson disputed that contention, telling the Times that the decreased total was due to "temporary data disruptions" that would be quickly fixed.

The South China Morning Post also reported on the removal, noting that the four fallen soldiers were no longer listed as part of the Iran war death toll but have been placed in a new, separate category on the Defense Casualty Analysis System (DCAS) called "Overseas Operations." This category lists the four Army deaths by name as well as 207 wounded. Pentagon press secretary Joel Valdez argued on Thursday that the drop in casualty figures was not an effort to hide the growing human toll of the war but rather the result of "anomalies" and "temporary data disruptions" that were being resolved "imminently."

Meanwhile, the Jerusalem Post focused on the upcoming ceremony for the four soldiers at Dover Air Force Base in Delaware, which Trump is scheduled to attend. The ceremony, known as a "dignified transfer" of the bodies, comes amid growing frustration with the war, which has cost US taxpayers at least $37.5 billion so far, has led to the deaths of 18 US service members and injured more than 450 troops, and has killed thousands of Iranians.

Key Claims

  • The Pentagon's official list of service members killed in the Iran war does not include the four soldiers who died over the weekend.
  • The number of US military personnel killed during Operation Epic Fury remains at 14, according to the Pentagon's Defense Casualty Analysis System website.
  • The Pentagon website listed 18 American service members as killed on Wednesday, but was changed on Thursday to exclude four service members killed over the weekend.
  • A new category called "Overseas Operations" emerged on the Pentagon's website, listing the four Army deaths by name as well as 207 wounded.
  • The war has cost US taxpayers at least $37.5 billion, with 18 US service members killed and over 450 troops injured.
  • Thousands of Iranians have been killed in the war.
  • Trump claimed that the dead soldiers supported his claim that the war on Iran is necessary to prevent that nation from developing a nuclear weapon.
  • Pentagon press secretary Joel Valdez attributed the drop in casualty figures to "anomalies" and "temporary data disruptions" that were being resolved "imminently."

Perspectives

Pentagon: Pentagon press secretary Joel Valdez says the drop in casualty figures is due to "anomalies" and "temporary data disruptions" that are being resolved, and denies any effort to hide the human toll of the war.

Military officials (unnamed): Three military officials told the New York Times that the Trump administration decided to remove the four service members from the list because their deaths occurred after Trump declared a cease-fire in the war in April.