Lead
Five former US officials, including a retired top military lawyer, have criticized the Pentagon for not publicly addressing possible American involvement in a deadly strike on a school in Minab, Iran, during Operation Epic Fury, as reported by the BBC and the Jerusalem Post. The strike, which occurred on February 28, killed 168 people, including around 110 children, according to Iranian officials. The Pentagon has only said the incident remains under investigation.
Coverage Comparison
Both the BBC and the Jerusalem Post reported on the criticism from former officials and the Pentagon's lack of detail. The BBC provided extensive quotes from former officials and noted that the Pentagon's response strikingly departs from historical norms. The Jerusalem Post focused on the timeline and the number of casualties, framing the story neutrally.
Key Claims
- Verified video shows damage and smoke at the Iranian school in Minab, as reported by the BBC.
- Five former US officials criticized the Pentagon for not acknowledging potential American involvement, according to both sources.
- The Pentagon has said the incident is under investigation, a statement confirmed by both outlets.
- US media reported in early March that military investigators believed American forces were likely responsible for unintentionally hitting the school, though no final conclusion has been reached. This claim has been reported by multiple outlets but remains unconfirmed by the Pentagon.
- President Trump accused Iran of hitting the school on March 7, without providing evidence, as reported by both sources.
- A US Tomahawk missile struck an Iranian Revolutionary Guard Corps base next to the school, according to a single outlet (the Jerusalem Post). This claim has not been independently verified.
- The strike occurred on February 28 at the beginning of Operation Epic Fury, as reported by the Jerusalem Post.
- A missile hit a primary school killing 168 people, including around 110 children, according to Iranian officials, as reported by the Jerusalem Post.
Perspectives
Former US officials, including retired Lt. Col. Rachel E. VanLandingham, a former senior legal adviser at US Central Command, argue that the Pentagon's silence is unprecedented and undermines accountability. VanLandingham said the current position "strikingly departs from the standard response" and lacks a "commitment to the law of war."
The Pentagon maintains that the incident is under investigation and that more details will be provided when available, as stated in response to questions from the BBC.
President Trump has publicly blamed Iran for the strike, but has not provided evidence, while US media reports suggest American forces may have been responsible. The situation remains unresolved, with multiple parties potentially responsible, according to the coverage.