A Shifting Offensive Landscape

The Green Bay Packers enter the 2025 season with significant changes to their roster. All-Pro pass-rusher Micah Parsons, acquired in a trade with the Dallas Cowboys, will begin the season on the reserve/Physically Unable to Perform (PUP) list after tearing his ACL and damaging his meniscus last season, as reported by Yardbarker. Meanwhile, running back Josh Jacobs has been placed on the commissioner's exempt list following misdemeanor charges, according to the Green Bay Press-Gazette.

Jacobs' placement on the exempt list came Aug. 30, three months after his arrest in late May. He was recently charged with two misdemeanors, including battery, and misdemeanor criminal damage to property, according to multiple reports. The NFL's personal conduct policy allows commissioner Roger Goodell to keep Jacobs on the list indefinitely, and the league can suspend him based on its investigation regardless of the legal outcome, as noted by the Green Bay Press-Gazette.

The Running Back Conundrum

With Jacobs unavailable, the Packers' backfield lacks a proven workhorse. Over the past two seasons, Jacobs averaged 19 touches and 87 yards per game, a load that no current running back can replicate, according to the Green Bay Press-Gazette. MarShawn Lloyd has talent but a troubling health history, and Kaleb Johnson had just 29 touches in 10 games with the Steelers last season. Chris Brooks is primarily a special-teams and third-down back, not an early-down runner.

ESPN NFL insider Adam Schefter, speaking on Monday's edition of "Get Up," echoed concerns about the Packers' running back situation. "(The Packers) are going to have to score points now without a proven running back," Schefter said. "Kaleb Johnson washed out in Pittsburgh. MarShawn Lloyd has never taken a snap at the NFL level due to injuries ... Chris Brooks has run for 395 yards. So you're looking at under 500 yards for the three running backs that are on their roster until, and if and when, Josh Jacobs returns."

Love's Burden and Potential

This situation places the offensive burden squarely on quarterback Jordan Love. As the Green Bay Press-Gazette notes, the NFL is a quarterback-driven league, and Love is paid $55 million a year to make the offense go. His three years of acclimation as a starter are over; he must produce week in and week out.

Love has the weapons to help. Christian Watson is one of the league's best big-play receivers, ranking second in yards per reception. Matthew Golden had a strong training camp and showed chemistry with Love. Jayden Reed recently received a contract extension, and tight end Tucker Kraft is a top run-after-the-catch threat. However, health concerns abound: Watson has a history of injuries, Reed missed 10 games last season with a broken collarbone, Golden has a slight build, and Kraft is coming off a torn ACL.

Love's career bests came in 2023, when he threw for 4,159 yards and 32 touchdowns, and he has led the Packers to the playoffs in each of his three full seasons as starter. However, the team dropped its final five games last season after losing Parsons in Week 14, according to Yardbarker.

Defense Without Parsons

The Packers will also be without their defensive leader for at least the first four games. Parsons, who led the team in sacks and was the league leader in pressures last season, will not suit up, leaving a significant gap on defense. As Yardbarker notes, his absence will be felt, but the bigger immediate concern may be the offense's ability to score without Jacobs.

The Exempt List Precedent

There is precedent for players missing significant time on the exempt list without a conviction. Jabrill Peppers, then with New England, was placed on the exempt list in October 2024 following an alleged assault at his home. He missed seven games while on the list and was allowed back before his case went through the courts; he was eventually acquitted. Peppers' charges were felony battery, whereas Jacobs' are misdemeanors, as reported by the Green Bay Press-Gazette.

The exempt list theoretically is not punishment, as the player continues to be paid. However, if Jacobs is later suspended, time on the exempt list counts toward that suspension, and he would have to return his salary from those games. In Peppers' case, he went on the list two days after his arrest; Jacobs went on three months after his, giving the league time to investigate.

Outlook and Reactions

Packers head coach Matt LaFleur expressed cautious optimism about Jacobs' future with the team. "You've gotta let everything play out," LaFleur said, "but I anticipate him being a member of our football team."

Despite the challenges, some see an opportunity for Love to ascend. Micah Parsons, speaking on his "The Edge" podcast, predicted that Love will win the MVP award, throwing for about 40 touchdowns and over 4,000 yards. According to DraftKings, Love currently has the 11th-best odds of winning MVP at +2000, with all 10 players ahead of him being quarterbacks.

Love's court date is scheduled for Nov. 17, and with the legal process potentially lengthy, the Packers may have to navigate an extended period without their starting running back. As the Green Bay Press-Gazette notes, there are too many unknowns to say anything definitively, but the league's action suggests there's a good chance Jacobs misses at least six weeks, which is the minimum suspension under the league's domestic violence policy.

Until then, the Packers' fortunes rest on Love's arm and legs, and on a receiving corps that must stay healthy to carry the load.