Tertius News is an AI-native newsroom: an AI model reads the linked source articles below and extracts what each outlet reported, so you can compare their coverage side by side. How this works →
Objections against probe panel members
Subha Shankar Sarkar, the academic appointed to head a Jadavpur University probe into recent campus clashes, declined the role, citing logistical constraints. Following objections from a teachers' body and student demands, a retired Calcutta High Court judge, Pranab Chatterjee, has been named to lead the committee.
Professor declines role, retired judge to lead inquiry
Subha Shankar Sarkar, a retired academic appointed by Jadavpur University to head a committee investigating last week's campus violence, has declined the assignment, prompting the university to name a retired Calcutta High Court judge, Pranab Chatterjee, as his replacement. Vice-chancellor Chiranjib Bhattacharjee announced Chatterjee's appointment at a meeting of all stakeholders on Monday, according to The Times of India.
Sarkar, a former vice-chancellor of Netaji Subhas Open University, was initially appointed to lead the five-member committee formed on August 21 to probe clashes between ABVP and Left-leaning student groups. He informed the vice-chancellor via email on Saturday that he was unable to take on the role, citing prior commitments and his whereabouts in Delhi, where he said conducting interviews would not be feasible. The development was confirmed by the university's acting registrar, Selim Box Mandal, who said a new chairperson would be appointed shortly.
The committee's first meeting is scheduled for August 27, and its members are to include Chatterjee as head, with other members as previously constituted. The initial panel, as reported by Lokmat Times, included Sarkar as chair and Arunasish Goswami and Soumendu Chattopadhyay as members, but the later five-member structure was reported by The Hindu and The Times of India.
Objections over neutrality
The university announced the formation of the probe committee amid competing complaints about the violence. The RSS-affiliated ABVP alleged that Left student organisations, including SFI and DSO-DSF, instigated confrontations under the cover of a FETSU meeting, while Left-leaning groups accused ABVP of bringing outsiders onto campus and vandalising property.
Shortly after the committee's formation, the Akhil Bharatiya Rashtriya Shaikshik Mahasangh (ABRSM), the teachers' wing of the RSS, wrote to the vice-chancellor objecting to the appointment of the committee chairman, Professor Subha Shankar Sarkar, and the presenting officer, Abul Hasnat. The organisation cited a High Court order that had led to Sarkar's removal from the West Bengal School Service Commission in January 2022 after his name surfaced in connection with the teacher recruitment scam. It also alleged irregularities in Hasnat's appointment process and demanded that the committee be dissolved and an independent probe be carried out by retired Calcutta High Court or Supreme Court judges.
A JU insider, however, told Lokmat Times that Sarfar had emailed his disinclination before ABRSM formally objected, making it unclear whether his decision was influenced by their opposition.
Sarkar, speaking to The Times of India from Delhi, said he had not formally accepted the offer but had merely taken time to evaluate its feasibility. He added that the inquiry would require daily interactions with campus personnel and that an online probe would not be effective.
Police start probe and faculty committee dissolved
The police formally began their investigation on Monday when a team visited the campus to collect CCTV footage and inspect the locations of the clashes, which took off early on August 20, according to The Times of India. No arrests have been made yet. The campus suffered a second round of assault on the afternoon of August 20, during which the university emblem was damaged.
The clashes, which started early on August 20, involved accusations and counter-accusations between the RSS-affiliated ABVP and Left-leaning groups, both sides accusing the other of bringing outsiders onto campus.
In a separate development, the university authorities dissolved the committee of its nodal student grievance cell, which was headed by former Vice-Chancellor Buddhadeb Sau, after CCTV footage emerged showing Sau entering the campus around the time of a right-wing rampage and speaking with an ABVP member, Subhabrata Adhikary, while vandalism was underway. Students across the university have demanded that any insiders who aided the attack be investigated and suspended, and that a probe be conducted into the security lapses.
During the Monday stakeholder meeting, the vice-chancellor, Chichib Bhattacharjee, fell while leaving the meeting room, with a source reporting a ruckus as students insisted he not leave until the meeting was unfinished. He was helped to his car and taken to a nearby facility, the incident reported.
The university has also issued a notice that anyone may submit their depositions to the committee by August 27.
Perspectives
ABRSM (University unit) – The organization raised objections to the committee's neutrality, targeting the chairman and presenting officer for past allegations, and demanded an independent panel of retired judges.
University Administration – Vice-Chancellor stated that a replacement for Sarkar would be found, and the decision to appoint a retired judge was announced.
Professor Subha Shankar Sarkar – Clarified that he had not accepted the role but had considered feasibility and stepped down due to his Delhi placement.
Students – Demanded a transparent inquiry and suspension of insiders caught on CCTV footage, and pressed the vice-chancellor to address their demands.
How each outlet told it
Lokmat Times
Framing: States Sarkar refused to take charge — Neutral reporting
Facts Included:
Head of probe committee declines assignment
Committee was three-member to probe clashes between SFI and ABVP
Sarkar was former VC of Netaji Subhas Open University
Other members were Arunasish Goswami and Soumendu Chattopadhyay
Sarkar emailed disinclination on Saturday evening
Objections by ABRSM regarding Sarkar's involvement in teacher recruitment cases during TMC regime
JU insider noted Sarkar emailed before ABRSM's official objection
Two options for JU: replace Sarkar or form new panel
CM Suvendu Adhikari's statement about ending anti-national activities and establishing nationalism
Framing: Headlines ask why the committee head resigned, but the article does not provide an answer to that question — Slightly sensationalist headline but neutral reporting
Facts Included:
Professor Subha Shankar Sarkar resigned as head of the probe committee
Resignation due to inability to conduct inquiry effectively
University to appoint new head
Sarkar's email to VC on Saturday
Confirmation by acting registrar Selim Box Mandal
Sarkar's statement about being in Delhi and need for physical interactions
Clash between ABVP and Left-leaning groups on August 20
ABRSM opposed Sarkar's appointment
Sarkar's removal from West Bengal School Service Commission in Jan 2022
Framing: Focuses on objections raised by ABRSM against probe panel members — Reportorial, presenting ABRSM's objections without additional commentary
Facts Included:
ABRSM JU unit wrote to VC Chiranjib Bhattacharjee objecting to the neutrality of the investigation committee
Objections against committee chairman Professor Subha Shankar Sarkar and presenting officer Abul Hasnat
Allegation that Professor Sarkar was removed from School Service Commission following a High Court order due to teacher recruitment scam links
Allegation of irregularity in Abul Hasnat's appointment process
Demand for dissolution of current committee and formation of independent and impartial investigation by retired judges of Calcutta High Court or Supreme Court
Framing: Highlights the appointment of a retired judge as the new probe head following right-wing demand — Reportorial but includes loaded terms like 'right-wing mob' and highlights controversial actions by Sau and ABVP
Facts Included:
Calcutta High Court ex-judge Pranab Chatterjee to head the five-member committee
VC Chiranjib Bhattacharjee announced the decision at a stakeholders' meeting on Monday
Subha Shankar Sarkar refused to head the committee
ABRSM had objected to Sarkar's appointment and demanded a retired judge
First committee meeting on Aug 27
JU dissolved the students' grievance cell committee headed by former VC Buddhadeb Sau
CCTV footage showed Sau entering campus when right-wing mob was on rampage
Sau talking to Subhabrata Adhikary, an ABVP member, while vandalism occurred
Demand to suspend 'insiders' who helped outsiders
Sau's response defending himself and criticizing VC's indecisiveness
VC emailed higher education department about possible students' union election
Each row is one claim, attributed to the outlet whose wording states it most clearly. Confidence rates how directly the source text states the claim — explicit and unhedged rates high; hedged, pieced-together, or internally inconsistent statements rate lower. It does not measure whether the claim is true. Status counts the distinct outlets we found asserting it — so a single-source claim can still show high confidence, and a multi-source claim can show medium. Every one of those outlets is named beside the status, so you can check the count against the list. For claims extracted before we began storing that list, the row says so: it names the outlet the claim is quoted from and states that we have not recorded which outlets backed it. Outlets wrote at different times, so a figure that evolves — a casualty count, for example — can legitimately differ between rows; check the "as of" time next to each claim's source.
Claim
Confidence
Status
ClaimABRSM, JU unit, wrote to vice-chancellor Chiranjib Bhattacharjee objecting to the neutrality of the investigation committee formed to probe the Aug 19-20 incident.
ClaimABRSM alleged that following a High Court order, Professor Sarkar was previously removed from his position in the School Service Commission after his name surfaced in the teacher recruitment scam.
ClaimABRSM demanded the dissolution of the current committee and sought an independent and impartial investigation comprising retired judges of the Calcutta High Court or the Supreme Court of India.
ClaimCalcutta High Court ex-judge Pranab Chatterjee will head the five-member committee set up by Jadavpur University to probe campus vandalism and violence on Aug 19 and 20.
ClaimCCTV footage showed Buddhadeb Sau talking to Subhabrata Adhikary, a member of the central working committee of ABVP, while outsiders were vandalising the premises.
ClaimStudents across faculties and political organisations demanded that 'insiders' who helped 'outsiders' storm the campus be brought within the purview of the investigation and suspended.
ClaimVC Bhattacharjee had emailed the higher education department seeking a tripartite meeting to discuss the possibility of an early students union election.
ClaimA clash broke out between members of ABVP and Left-leaning student groups at Jadavpur University early on August 20, with both sides accusing each other of bringing outsiders onto the campus.
ClaimSarkar was removed as the chairman of the West Bengal School Service Commission in January 2022 following proceedings before the Calcutta High Court over alleged irregularities in recruitments.
ClaimStudents at the meeting demanded inclusion of student representatives in the inquiry committee and temporary suspension of 'insiders' caught on CCTV footage.
ClaimWhile being escorted by guards, a ruckus occurred and the VC fell in front of the estate section, hurting his leg, and was taken out via gate one on an emergency basis.
ClaimABRSM objected to Sarkar's appointment on grounds that his name was involved in teachers' recruitment cases during the previous Mamata Banerjee-led Trinamool Congress regime.
ClaimA JU insider pointed out that Sarkar emailed the university authorities refusing before ABRSM officially raised objections, so it cannot be said for certain his decision had anything to do with ABRSM's objections.
ClaimChief Minister Suvendu Adhikari said he is determined to end anti-national activities at JU and establish the spirit of nationalism there 'at any cost'.
ClaimA police team would visit the campus on Monday to collect CCTV footage, marking the formal start of the probe 96 hours after a right-wing mob went on a rampage early on Aug 20.
ClaimVC Bhattacharjee said 'Professor Sarkar expressed regret and communicated to me on Saturday that he would not be able to take on this responsibility, citing personal reasons. We will now have to find a replacement.'
ClaimSarkar told TOI from Delhi that he had not accepted the offer but merely took time to evaluate feasibility, and sent the letter the following day.
ClaimABRSM wrote to VC Bhattacharjee objecting to Sarkar's appointment, citing his alleged involvement in irregularities in recruitments by the Bengal school service commission.
ClaimABRSM urged the VC to appoint persons of 'unimpeachable independence, integrity and professional standing — preferably retired Judges of Calcutta High Court or Supreme Court of India' as committee members.
ClaimPolice requested the JU authorities for relevant CCTV footage and permission to inspect locations where clashes broke out, and the university requested officers to visit campus on Monday.
ClaimThe RSS-affiliated ABVP alleged that members of Left student organisations, including SFI and DSO-DSF, started confrontations under the cover of a FETSU meeting.