Lead

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan's National Assembly was adjourned on Tuesday without transacting any business, as a persistent quorum crisis continued to disrupt proceedings. The session, which began on May 11, saw its sitting suspended after the house repeatedly failed to meet the required quorum. The development drew sharp criticism from within the ruling coalition, with a PPP lawmaker blaming the absence of PML-N members for the collapse.

Separately, the government denied reports of mass deportation of Pakistanis from the UAE, calling them "incorrect and false," while providing figures for deportations from Gulf countries over the last five years.

Coverage Comparison

Two reports from Dawn, Pakistan's leading English-language daily, covered the events. The first focused on the opposition's protest on Monday demanding proper medical care for incarcerated PTI founder Imran Khan and the government's denial of deportations from the UAE. The second detailed Tuesday's adjournment due to lack of quorum and the criticism from treasury benches.

Both reports share a neutral tone but differ in emphasis. The Monday report highlights opposition actions, while the Tuesday report centers on the quorum failure and internal government criticism. Neither report provides commentary from independent analysts or opposition leaders beyond direct quotes.

Key Claims

The National Assembly session was adjourned due to lack of quorum, as reported by Dawn. According to the report, PTI-backed independent MNA Iqbal Afridi pointed out the quorum, and after bells were rung, the house remained inquorate. Deputy Speaker Ghulam Mustafa Shah adjourned proceedings initially for 15 minutes, then until Wednesday when the quorum was still not met.

Each sitting of the National Assembly costs around Rs24 million to the national exchequer, according to a National Assembly official quoted by Dawn. The report also alleged that many members sign the attendance register for TA/DA and leave for private engagements.

On Monday, opposition lawmakers staged a protest on the National Assembly floor, demanding proper medical care for Imran Khan, as reported by Dawn. According to the report, leader of opposition Mehmood Khan Achakzai said a deadline given to the government had expired and announced the opposition would boycott the budget session. His speech was cut off and not broadcast on official channels.

The government denied deportation of Pakistanis from the UAE, with Parliamentary Affairs Minister Dr Tariq Fazal Chaudhary stating that reports of mass deportation were "incorrect and false," and described them as "social media creations." He added that no complaints had been received.

Dawn also reported that a total of 164,788 Pakistanis had been deported from Gulf countries in the last five years, including 108,029 from Saudi Arabia, 40,497 from the UAE, 9,814 from Oman, 2,971 from Qatar, 2,779 from Bahrain, and 698 from Kuwait.

Perspectives

The quorum crisis has drawn frustration from within the ruling coalition. PPP MNA Sharmila Farooqi posted on X that it was "deeply frustrating to sit in the National Assembly day after day only to see the quorum repeatedly pointed out by the opposition because the treasury benches remain empty." She noted that "nearly 95 per cent of PML-N MNAs are absent," and emphasized that it was not PPP's responsibility to complete the quorum. She also pointed out that sessions were collapsing despite efforts, wasting "millions of rupees of taxpayers' money" daily.

The opposition, led by PTI-backed MNAs, has linked the quorum issue to their demand for Imran Khan's medical care. Achakzai's deadline and the boycott announcement suggest a deepening standoff between the opposition and the government over the treatment of the former premier.

The government's denial of deportations from the UAE, while providing data on deportations from Gulf countries, appears aimed at countering social media reports. However, the figures themselves indicate a significant number of deportations over five years, which may fuel further debate.

As of now, the National Assembly is set to meet again on Wednesday, but with the quorum issue unresolved and tensions high, the coming days may see continued disruption.