Coverage Comparison

Reports from The Guardian, which first broke the news of the settlement, indicate that Louisiana's state police and a local sheriff's office have agreed to pay $4.85 million to the daughter of Ronald Greene, a Black motorist who died in 2019 following a violent arrest. The settlement was reached during mediation talks that concluded on May 12, according to a source with direct knowledge of the discussions. An attorney for Greene's daughter, Tayla, did not immediately respond to requests for comment, and spokespeople for Louisiana Governor Jeff Landry and Attorney General Liz Murrill were also unreachable.

Greene, 49, died after being shocked with stun guns, punched, and dragged during an arrest outside Monroe, Louisiana. Body-camera footage, withheld for two years but published by the Associated Press in 2021, showed officers swarming Greene, using stun guns on him, and putting him in a chokehold. The footage contradicted initial official claims that Greene died from a crash following a high-speed chase.

Key Claims

  • A $4.85 million settlement has been agreed between Louisiana authorities and Greene's family, subject to approval by the state legislature.
  • The settlement would end a federal wrongful death lawsuit filed by Greene's daughter, Tayla.
  • Body-camera footage showed officers punching, kicking, and using stun guns on Greene, contradicting initial reports of a crash.
  • Two officers were charged with misdemeanor battery and pleaded no contest.
  • Federal prosecutors did not pursue charges, but a state grand jury indicted four troopers and a deputy on charges ranging from negligent homicide to malfeasance.
  • The US Justice Department found that Louisiana's state police engaged in a pattern of excessive force during arrests and car chases.

Perspectives

Greene's Family and Attorney

Ben Crump, the attorney for Greene's family, stated that no amount of money can erase the pain inflicted on his loved ones, but the settlement helps illustrate how 'the truth must always come to light.' Greene's mother, Mona Hardin, has expressed outrage over the circumstances of her son's death, emphasizing the need for accountability.

Authorities and Legal Proceedings

The settlement was reached without admission of liability. While two officers pleaded no contest to misdemeanor battery, four troopers and a deputy were indicted by a state grand jury on more serious charges, though the outcomes of those cases have not been fully reported. Federal prosecutors declined to pursue charges, citing insufficient evidence.

Official Explanations and Public Reaction

Initial official explanations attributed Greene's death to a crash following a high-speed chase, but the release of body-camera footage and other evidence—including a hospital report noting stun gun prongs in Greene's back and an emergency room doctor questioning the crash theory—led to public outrage and calls for transparency. The case also prompted a Justice Department investigation that found a pattern of excessive force within Louisiana State Police.