'Know your place': Gotliv calls for IDF chief Zamir's dismissal after his criticism of draft law

Lead

A political firestorm erupted this week over IDF Chief of Staff Lt.-Gen. Eyal Zamir's warning against proposed legislation that would freeze arrests of haredi (ultra-Orthodox) draft dodgers, with coalition lawmakers calling for his dismissal and former prime minister Naftali Bennett defending him.

Zamir sent a letter to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Defense Minister Israel Katz — a letter that was clearly intentionally leaked to the media — warning that implementing the law would create an array of national security problems, saying he opposes its implementation "completely and unequivocally," as reported by the Jerusalem Post. The law would exempt haredim from arrest when they dodge their legal obligations under Israel's existing military draft laws.

Coverage comparison

Reporting by the Jerusalem Post over several days shows the controversy unfolding in stages. Zamir's letter, sent Monday, was met with immediate criticism from Shas leader MK Aryeh Deri, who accused the chief of staff of political interference. By Tuesday, Likud MKs Tally Gotliv and Osher Shekalim had joined the attack, with Gotliv explicitly calling for Zamir's firing. Meanwhile, former prime minister Naftali Bennett came to Zamir's defense, and the Jerusalem Post's editorial board argued that Zamir's warning fell within his professional duty.

The Post's coverage frames the dispute primarily as a question of whether the military's top officer overstepped his authority by publicly weighing in on a legislative matter. Some reports characterize Zamir's actions as a "dangerous precedent," while an editorial argues that his warning was a professional obligation, not political advocacy.

Key claims

The core dispute centers on Zamir's letter, in which he argued that the proposed law would decrease recruitment both from the haredi community and from the general Israeli population by delegitimizing the idea of the IDF as the "nation's army" in which everyone is equally obligated to serve. He also said the IDF should not be put in the position of judging which yeshiva students deserve an exemption and which do not, as it has no expertise in this area, its expertise being in fighting wars, according to the Jerusalem Post.

The chief of staff further warned that the anger and acrimony such a law would create within the military would harm its cohesiveness at a critical time when it is on guard on several fronts and coping with historic gaps in troop levels because the government has failed for three-and-a-half years to recruit more haredim or to extend the mandatory and reservist recruitment laws.

Zamir, who for months has warned that the IDF is facing a critical manpower shortage and needs an influx of 12,000 soldiers, wrote that the legislation would create a disincentive to report for military service since it grants immunity from prosecution and criminal proceedings during the freeze, the Post reported. In recent months, Zamir also privately warned the security cabinet that 10 red flags were going up about IDF troop shortages coming up in January 2027, due to the government ignoring the issue.

Gotliv, in a post on X/Twitter, wrote: "Chief of Staff Eyal Zamir, I suggest you know your place!! Know your place!! I am of course not threatening, because I have no authority in my hands. But your disgraceful letter from yesterday requires your dismissal." She added that Zamir had "dared to step onto the political field and, in doing so, weaken the morale of our soldiers and the citizens of Israel."

Shekalim echoed the criticism, arguing in an interview with 103FM that Zamir's involvement went beyond his authority and harmed proper administration. "The chief of staff should be the number one soldier and nothing else," Shekalim said. "He is not supposed to be a lawmaker, and he is not supposed to set policy. He can say his piece to the prime minister behind closed doors and not take it outside." Asked whether Zamir should be removed from his post, Shekalim responded: "When the chief of staff speaks like that and attacks lawmakers, in my view he cannot continue in his position."

Deri, in an interview with Kikar HaShabbat, said Zamir has "no business getting involved in politics," accusing him of trying to help the left-wing bloc during the election period. "He has lost it," Deri said. "What the chief of staff did during the election period was try to help the left-wing bloc, unequivocally!

Perspectives

Coalition lawmakers (Deri, Gotliv, Shekalim): The chief of staff overstepped his authority by publicly intervening in a legislative matter. They describe his letter as political interference that weakens morale and harms proper administration, with Gotliv and Shekalim calling for his removal.

IDF Chief of Staff Lt.-Gen. Eyal Zamir (via his letter): The proposed legislation would harm national security by decreasing recruitment, delegitimizing the IDF as the "nation's army," and undermining military cohesion at a critical time of manpower shortages.

Former Prime Minister Naftali Bennett: Defended Zamir against Deri's attack, saying such criticism of the military's chief could only happen "in the October 7 government," and praised Zamir's warning as the chief of staff "once again warning of an impending disaster."

Jerusalem Post editorial board: While acknowledging that active-duty generals should generally stay out of politics, the editorial argued that Zamir's warning was not political advocacy but a professional duty to alert the government that the proposed legislation would undermine the IDF's ability to fulfill its missions.