September Streaming: Weighing the Value of Paramount+ and Disney+

As the streaming calendar picks up in September with new seasons and fall premieres, subscribers may want to reconsider which services earn a recurring charge. A Tom's Guide survey on streaming habits found that readers are spending more than $60 a month on seven or more streaming services. With costs accumulating, the outlet's analysis suggests treating subscriptions as a rotating lineup, canceling those with quieter months and resubscribing when new content arrives.

For September 2026, Tom's Guide identifies Paramount+ and the Hulu/Disney+ bundle as the two services the author would be most comfortable canceling. Both have recognizable franchises and occasional must-watch hits, but this month's offerings don't justify another monthly fee, according to the analysis.

Paramount+ September Highlights

Despite the recommendation to cancel, Paramount+ has several notable releases in September, as detailed by Us Weekly. The biggest draw is the return of "MobLand" for a second season, starring Tom Hardy, Helen Mirren and Pierce Brosnan in what the outlet describes as "turf warfare and thick English accents." New episodes arrive weekly starting September 18.

Other Paramount+ originals include "The Varnell Hill Show" on September 1 and the streaming premiere of the 2026 "Scary Movie" reboot, available with an extended cut on September 3. The 2026 MTV Video Music Awards air on September 27, and "South Park" season 29 premieres with next-day availability in the US, Canada, and Australia on September 17.

Reality TV fans have "Survivor" season 51 on September 23, "The Amazing Race" season 39 with a two-night premiere on September 30, and the 2026 MTV Movie Awards on September 27. CBS specials include "Daughters of 9/11" on September 11 and "Comics Unleashed 20th Anniversary" on September 29.

Tom's Guide notes the other notable drops are "Colin From Accounts" season 3 and the "Scary Movie" streaming premiere. The NFL remains a potential reason to keep the service, as CBS's Sunday games can be watched for free with a TV antenna.

Disney+ September Offerings

On the Disney+ side, the biggest new addition is "LEGO Star Wars: The Mandalorian," an animated special arriving September 2 according to Tom's Guide. "Dancing With the Stars" also returns on September 22. The Hulu/Disney+ bundle offers more overall, the outlet acknowledges, but this month's content may not be compelling enough for a month-long subscription.

Potential Savings

The financial case for canceling both services is straightforward. For standard ad-supported plans, canceling Paramount+ and Disney+ for one month saves roughly $19. For ad-free plans, the savings reach around $30 a month, which adds up to $360 over a year, according to Tom's Guide.