Tertius News is an AI-native newsroom: an AI model reads the linked source articles below and extracts what each outlet reported, so you can compare their coverage side by side. How this works →
Free hand to police to deal with gangsters in West Bengal: Dilip Ghosh
West Bengal minister Dilip Ghosh said the BJP government has given police a free hand to act against gangsters, warning of encounters as a last resort. He criticized the previous TMC regime for allegedly nurturing mafia and backed police excess as preferable to unchecked crime.
Minister's Remarks at Kharagpur BJP Office Inauguration
West Bengal Panchayat Minister Dilip Ghosh, speaking at the inauguration of a BJP party office in his Kharagpur assembly constituency, said the state government has given police a free hand to act against gangsters. He declared that “threat culture” has become a thing of the past and asked police to adopt a zero-tolerance approach toward criminal elements. “No mafia will be allowed to step foot on the soil of Kharagpur,” he asserted, as quoted by ThePrint and The Hindu.
Ghosh, who is also the MLA of Kharagpur, said that if a crime is grave and the situation warrants, “encounter by the police will be the last resort.” He added that “police will only press the trigger to prevent criminal activities,” according to The New Indian Express.
Support for Police Excess
Ghosh defended police excesses, saying they are sometimes necessary to keep mafias and anti-social elements under control. “Let the police overreact. It is always better than allowing mafias and diehard anti-social elements to overreact,” he said, as quoted by Lokmat Times. Deccan Chronicle quoted him as saying, “Police excess is better than the excess by goons and mafia. Only then peace can prevail. We want to give people peace.”
He acknowledged complaints about police excess and said they would be addressed, noting that videos of police chasing and catching addicts have circulated. “The police have started their job. But many are now complaining of police excess,” he said, according to Deccan Chronicle.
Attack on Previous TMC Regime
Ghosh launched a scathing attack on the previous Mamata Banerjee-led Trinamool Congress regime, alleging that it nurtured mafia and anti-social elements by keeping police inactive. “Earlier, the police used to run the mafia kingdom in collaboration with gangsters and mafia leaders. Now, this will not happen,” he said, as reported by Lokmat Times. He said the new state government will not tolerate police personnel becoming party cadres.
The Times of India reported that Ghosh said criminal networks operated with political backing and police inaction in the past, causing local businesses to operate under fear. He said the administration has begun shutting down illegal operations, drug syndicates, and extortion, and that over 200 individuals involved in the drug trade have been detained.
Baruipur Encounter as Precedent
Ghosh cited the killing of Prabhas Mondal in Baruipur as an example of police action. Mondal, the main accused in the Baruipur minor rape and murder case, was shot dead on the night of July 8 while allegedly trying to escape from police custody during a crime scene reconstruction. Police said they retaliated in self-defence after the accused fired a round, as detailed by The New Indian Express.
The New Indian Express reported that Ghosh said the "Baruipur encounter policy" could be implemented in Kharagpur to eliminate local gangsters. "You (criminals) have to face bullets before you take your meal 'daal, bhat' soon after you step in Kharagpur," he warned.
Context of the Baruipur Case
The New Indian Express provided extensive background on the Baruipur incident. The victim's body was found in a sack in Surjyapur Haat on July 5. Residents protested by blocking roads, burning tyres, and damaging police vehicles. Hours after the body was recovered, a man identified as Indrajit Mondal was lynched by a mob on suspicion of involvement. Authorities imposed Section 163 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita in Baruipur, Narendrapur, and Sonarpur areas. The preliminary post-mortem report found injuries to the girl's private parts, scratches, bite marks, and a head injury.
Hope for Peace Before Durga Puja
Ghosh expressed hope that peace would be restored in the Kharagpur area before Durga Puja, as reported by The New Indian Express. He said "threat culture" has become a thing of the past in West Bengal, and that no mafia will be allowed to operate in Kharagpur.
The minister's remarks have drawn attention for their strong language, but no official response from the TMC or other parties was included in the reports.
Perspectives
Dilip Ghosh: The minister argues that police excess is necessary to control mafia and anti-social elements, and that the previous TMC regime nurtured crime by keeping police inactive. He says the free hand given to police will restore peace.
No alternative viewpoint was provided in the material: The reports do not include any response from the Trinamool Congress, civil liberties groups, or other critics of the police's actions.
How each outlet told it
Deccan Chronicle
Framing: Headline uses 'Backs Police Excess, Encounter' which emphasizes the controversial aspects and frames it as support for excess; it omits the 'free hand' framing and the 'last resort' qualifier. — critical or alarmed, using phrases like 'police excess' and 'backing encounter'
Facts Included:
Dilip Ghosh is West Bengal panchayat minister
Spoke at BJP office inauguration in Kharagpur Sadar, West Midnapore
Said 'I have asked the cops to act like cops'
Said police will not behave like party cadres or mafia
Mentioned complaints about police excess
Said thieves and dacoits earlier visited Kharagpur from surrounding areas
Said police didn't do anything earlier
Mentioned videos of police chasing and catching addicts
Said encounters could happen as in Baruipur during escape of an accused
Said 'police excess is better than excess by goons and mafia'
Framing: Headline emphasizes necessity of police excesses to control mafias, omitting the 'free hand' and 'last resort' aspects. — neutral but slightly critical, using 'police excesses' and 'overreact'
Facts Included:
Dilip Ghosh is West Bengal Panchayat Affairs and Rural Development Minister
Spoke at inauguration of BJP party office in Kharagpur (Sadar)
Said at times police excesses are necessary to keep mafias and anti-social elements under control
Quoted: 'Let the police overreact. It is always better than allowing mafias and diehard anti-social elements to overreact.'
Said if police overreact, society will remain peaceful
Launched attack on previous Mamata Banerjee-led TMC regime for allegedly nurturing mafia
Said earlier police used to run mafia kingdom in collaboration with gangsters
Said new government will not tolerate police becoming party cadres
Reminded encounter killing of Prvas Mondal (spelled as Prvas) in Baruipur
Said 'No mafia or goons will be able to operate freely'
Said criminals will be shot and not provided with rice and lentils
Said 'police will pull the triggers if necessary'
Said harassment of common people will not be tolerated
Framing: Headline focuses on the 'Baruipur encounter policy' being implemented, which is a specific reference; it omits the 'free hand' and 'last resort' aspects. — neutral but detailed, providing background on Baruipur incident to contextualize Ghosh's statement
Facts Included:
Baruipur encounter policy will be implemented in Kharagpur
Dilip Ghosh is West Bengal panchayat minister and heavyweight in Suvendu Adhikari cabinet
Spoke at inauguration of BJP office in Kharagpur Sadar constituency
Said state government gave free hand to police
Said 'threat culture' is a thing of the past
Asked police to adopt zero-tolerance approach
Said no mafia will be allowed in Kharagpur
Hope peace restored before Durga Puja
Said 'Forget about what happened during the previous Trinamool Congress rule'
Said 'encounter by the police will be the last resort'
Said 'Police will only press the trigger to prevent criminal activities'
Said criminals will face bullets before taking 'daal, bhat'
Detailed Baruipur incident: Prabhas Mondal shot dead on night of 8 July
Mondal was main accused in Baruipur minor rape and murder case
He was shot while trying to escape during crime scene reconstruction at 12:45 a.m.
Police said they retaliated in self-defence after accused fired
Mondal declared dead at Baruipur Hospital
Accused had been seen with victim in CCTV footage
Other accused: Ananda Sardar, Dibakar Sardar, Bashir Mallick
Victim's body found in sack in Surjyapur Haat on July 5
Framing: Headline emphasizes free hand to police and names Dilip Ghosh; it leaves out the context of encounter as last resort and the specific Baruipur reference. — neutral, reporting the minister's statements without elaboration
Facts Included:
Dilip Ghosh is West Bengal Panchayat Minister and Kharagpur MLA
Spoke at a function on Sunday
Said 'threat culture' is a thing of the past in West Bengal
Asked police to adopt zero-tolerance approach towards criminal elements
Said no mafia will be allowed in Kharagpur
Said BJP government gave free hand to police to act against mafia and gangsters
Said encounter by police will be last resort if crime is grave
Framing: Headline quotes 'Police will pull trigger if needed', emphasizing the threat and action, omitting context of 'last resort' and 'free hand'. — neutral but firm, presenting the minister's strong statements
Facts Included:
Dilip Ghosh is Bengal panchayat minister and MLA of Kharagpur Town
Spoke at inauguration of party office in Ward No. 2 of Kharagpur
Said police officers will 'draw their weapons and pull the trigger if necessary'
Said cops had been given a free hand to act against criminals
Said no mafia or gangster will be allowed to operate
Said individuals entering Kharagpur to cause disruption will face direct police action, including encounters as seen in Baruipur
Said police excesses were preferable to unchecked criminal activity
Said law enforcement instructed to act professionally, not as party cadres
Said over 200 individuals involved in drug trade have been detained
Said criminal networks operated with political backing and police inaction in past
Said local businesses operated under fear
Said administration has begun shutting down illegal operations, drug syndicates, extortion
Framing: Headline is identical to ThePrint's, emphasizing free hand and naming Ghosh; it does not mention the encounter context. — neutral, reporting statements without analysis
Facts Included:
Dilip Ghosh is West Bengal Panchayat Minister and Kharagpur MLA
Each row is one claim, attributed to the outlet whose wording states it most clearly. Confidence rates how directly the source text states the claim — explicit and unhedged rates high; hedged, pieced-together, or internally inconsistent statements rate lower. It does not measure whether the claim is true. Status counts the distinct outlets we found asserting it — so a single-source claim can still show high confidence, and a multi-source claim can show medium. Every one of those outlets is named beside the status, so you can check the count against the list. For claims extracted before we began storing that list, the row says so: it names the outlet the claim is quoted from and states that we have not recorded which outlets backed it. Outlets wrote at different times, so a figure that evolves — a casualty count, for example — can legitimately differ between rows; check the "as of" time next to each claim's source.
Claim
Confidence
Status
ClaimDilip Ghosh is the West Bengal Panchayat Minister and the MLA of Kharagpur.
ClaimDilip Ghosh said that criminal networks operated with political backing and police inaction in the past, causing local businesses to operate under fear.
ClaimDilip Ghosh said that no mafia or goons will be able to operate freely; if they resort to anti-social activities, they will be shot and not provided with rice and lentils.
ClaimOn the night of 8 July, Prabhas Mondal, the main accused in the Baruipur minor rape and murder case, was shot dead while seeking to escape from police custody during the reconstruction of the crime scene.
ClaimThe accused was taken to the crime scene in Baruipur at around 12:45 a.m. on the intervening night of 8 July for the reconstruction of the crime scene.
ClaimAccording to police, while trying to reconstruct the crime scene after midnight, Mondal tried to snatch the firearm and escape, and police retaliated in self-defence after the accused fired one round.
ClaimAuthorities imposed Section 163 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) in Baruipur, Narendrapur, and Sonarpur areas of South 24 Parganas to maintain law and order.
ClaimThe preliminary post-mortem report found injuries to the girl's private parts, along with scratches and bite marks, and indicated her head was struck with a heavy object or banged against a hard surface.
6 outlets · 6 articles consulted: Deccan Chronicle, Lokmat Times, The New Indian Express, ThePrint, The Times of India, The Hindu — World40 claims extractedVersion 1Written 2026-08-24