Lead

Former Victorian Liberal leader Matthew Guy has vehemently denied an allegation by fellow MP Moira Deeming that he assaulted her at a community event in Melbourne's west, with Victoria Police closing its investigation after finding no offence was committed. Guy is now considering legal action and demanding a public apology from Deeming, who has refused to give one.

The incident occurred at a Macedonian community event in Sunshine on May 23. Deeming reported the matter to Opposition Leader Jess Wilson's office before going to police on June 16. She alleged Guy had put her in a headlock. Video obtained by the ABC appeared to show Guy placing his arm on Deeming's back to speak with her at the crowded event.

Victoria Police confirmed late on Thursday night that it had concluded its investigation, stating, "Following a thorough investigation, it has been determined there was no offence detected." Police also noted that the woman did not require medical attention.

Coverage Comparison

ABC Australia's coverage of the story has evolved from initially reporting the allegation and the police investigation to focusing on the fallout within the Liberal Party. Earlier reports presented the facts neutrally, while later articles used critical language such as "bizarre," "damaging," and "unedifying" to describe the infighting. The Guardian — World also reported on the police investigation and Guy's denial, maintaining a neutral tone.

Key Claims

  • Deeming accused Guy of assault, alleging he put her in a headlock at a community event on May 23.
  • CCTV footage, obtained by the ABC, shows Guy placing his arm on Deeming's back during the interaction.
  • Victoria Police investigated and found no offence was committed.
  • Guy denies the allegation and is considering defamation action against Deeming.
  • Deeming first reported the incident to Opposition Leader Jess Wilson's office before going to police.
  • Guy has demanded an apology from Deeming, who has refused to apologize.
  • There is growing support among Liberal MPs for Deeming to be removed from the party room.

Perspectives

Matthew Guy: Vehemently denies the allegation, describing the claims as "ridiculous and unsubstantiated" in comments to The Age. He is considering defamation legal action and has demanded a public apology from Deeming, stating that his family also deserves an apology.

Moira Deeming: Has not publicly commented on the police finding but refuses to apologize to Guy. Reports suggest she later said she misunderstood the "technical meaning" of "headlock." There is growing support for her removal from the party room.

Jess Wilson: As Opposition Leader, Wilson declined to comment while the investigation was underway, emphasizing the importance of due process and the presumption of innocence. She has not commented since the police concluded their investigation.

Victoria Police: Conducted a thorough investigation and determined there was no offence detected, while engaging with the woman who made the report.