Tertius News is an AI-native newsroom: an AI model reads the linked source articles below and extracts what each outlet reported, so you can compare their coverage side by side. How this works →
Emily Compagno Joins Fox News' 'The Five' as Co-Host
Fox News has announced that Emily Compagno will join 'The Five' as a full-time co-host starting Sept. 8, moving from her role on 'Outnumbered.' The network's CEO Suzanne Scott confirmed the appointment, filling the seat left by Jeanine Pirro. Compagno will join existing co-hosts Greg Gutfeld, Dana Perino, Jesse Watters, and rotating hosts Harold Ford Jr. and Jessica Tarlov.
Fox News announced Monday that Emily Compagno, co-host of the network's noon show "Outnumbered," will become a full-time co-host on its top-rated program "The Five," effective September 8. The move, confirmed by Fox News Media CEO Suzanne Scott, places Compagno alongside longtime co-hosts Greg Gutfeld, Dana Perino, and Jesse Watters, with Harold Ford Jr. and Jessica Tarlov continuing to rotate in the program's liberal chair.
Compagno will step down from "Outnumbered," where a rotating roster of Fox News personalities will fill her spot until a permanent replacement is named, according to multiple reports. The announcement marks a significant promotion for Compagno, who joined Fox News as a contributor in 2018 and became co-host of "Outnumbered" in 2021.
A Permanent Slot After Pirro's Departure
The move fills a permanent seat on "The Five" that has been empty since Jeanine Pirro left the program. According to Deadline, Pirro departed after President Trump appointed her as U.S. attorney for the District of Columbia in May 2025. Variety similarly reported that Pirro left last year to become interim U.S. Attorney for the District of Columbia, though the two outlets differ on the precise timing of the departure.
Compagno will join a show that, as Fox News highlighted, celebrated its 15th anniversary in July and is the most-watched cable news program. The network said "The Five" averaged 3.6 million total viewers and 322,000 in the key 25-54 demographic during the second quarter, and has been the highest-rated show in cable news for 19 consecutive quarters, a statistic echoed by the New York Post and Variety.
Fox News's statement did not specify the reason for the seat opening, but the network's own coverage noted the program's dominance in the 5 p.m. timeslot, commanding over 64% of all cable news viewers there.
Reactions from the Network and Compagno
Fox News Media CEO Suzanne Scott welcomed Compagno in a statement: "Emily is a highly accomplished host whose energy and talent have made her a standout across Fox News Media, and we are thrilled to officially welcome her to the show." She also highlighted the program's staying power: "Fifteen years later, 'The Five' remains a powerhouse and appointment viewing for millions of Americans."
Compagno expressed her excitement, saying, "I couldn't be more honored to join 'The Five,' a team I have long admired and have been fortunate to help alongside over the years." She added, "Having an official seat at the table on what I truly believe is the most fun show on television is an incredible privilege. I am grateful for the opportunity and can't wait to get started."
Compagno's Background and Career
Compagno's rise within Fox News has been carrying by a varied resume. She first joined the network as a legal analyst in 2018, and she also be a co-host of "Outnumbered" in 2021. According to Fox News and the New York Post, Compagno is the author of "Under His Wings," published by Fox News Books, which the Post describes as a No. 1 bestseller and Fox News says was a 2024 New York Times bestseller; the specifics vary slightly by outlet (the Post says it debuted at No. 1 on Amazon and the New York Times list in its first week).
She has also worked as a federal managing attorney and acting director at the Social Security Administration, served as a judicial extern for Judge John T. Noonan on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, and held legal positions in South Africa and Brazil, per the Post. Before law, Compagno was captain of the Oakland Raiders' cheerleading squad and was selected as an NFL ambassador, representing the league internationally, says the Post.
A Program Central to Fox's Lineup
"The Five," originally conceived in 2011 as a roundtable to give more airtime to Fox News contributors, has become the network's most-watched program. Its roundtable format features regulars debating politics, pop culture, and other current events. The show's success is seen as critical for Fox News, especially as the network approaches the 2026 midterm elections, which Variety predicts will draw a wider swath of viewers to competitors like MSNBC and CNN as well.
As "The Five" deepens its bench, Compagno's promotion stands as a formal recognition of the "standout" reputation she has cultivated across Fox News's platforms, including hosting a true crime podcast and working on a Fox Nation. The change is effective in less than a month, as the show continues to dominate cable ratings.
How each outlet told it
Fox News — World
Framing: The headline is declarative, stating the fact of Compagno joining, without extra characterization. — Promotional and positive, highlighting achievements and ratings success, with a celebratory tone.
Facts Included:
Emily Compagno will join 'The Five' as a new co-host, announced Monday.
She will debut Sept. 8.
She joins co-hosts Greg Gutfeld, Dana Perino, Jesse Watters, and rotating hosts Harold Ford Jr. and Jessica Tarlov.
Quote from Suzanne Scott: 'Fifteen years later, The Five remains a powerhouse...'
Compagno steps down from 'Outnumbered'.
Compagno joined Fox in 2018, joined 'Outnumbered' in 2021.
She is author of the 2024 New York Times bestseller 'Under His Wings'.
Before Fox, she was a criminal defense attorney, worked on the Ninth Circuit and at the Social Security Administration.
She was also a Raiderette captain and NFL Ambassador.
The Five celebrated its 15-year anniversary, is the most-watched cable news show, and averaged 3.6 million viewers and 322,000 in the 25-54 demo in Q2.
The show commands more than 64% of all cable news viewers in the 5pm ET timeslot.
The Five draws more Democratic viewers than CNN and MS NOW and is #1 among independents.
Framing: The headline states factually that Compagno was named co-host of 'The Five', with no additional characterization. — Neutral, informative; the tone is matter-of-fact, with no emotional language.
Facts Included:
Emily Compagno will join Fox News' The Five as a full-time co-host, effective Sept. 8.
She will depart the noon ET show Outnumbered.
She will join co-hosts Greg Gutfeld, Dana Perino, Jesse Watters, Harold Ford Jr., and Jessica Tarlov.
Compagno is taking a permanent slot previously occupied by Jeanine Pirro, who departed after Donald Trump appointed her as U.S. attorney in May 2025.
Compagno joined Fox News as a contributor in 2018 and was named co-host of Outnumbered in 2021.
Fox News Media CEO Suzanne Scott announced the new role on Monday.
The Five averaged 3.6 million viewers and 322,000 in the 25-54 demo in Q2 and is the highest rated show in cable news.
Framing: Headline is straightforward, just announcing the name of the new co-host, without any adjectives or context. — Neutral and factual; the tone is formal, relying on quotes from officials.
Facts Included:
Emily Compagno named full-time co-host of The Five.
Effective Sept. 8.
She will be join co-hosts Greg Gutfeld, Dana Perino, Jesse Watters, and rotating hosts Harold Ford Jr. and Jessica Tarlov.
She will step down from Outnumbered.
Compagno joined Fox in 2018 as a contributor.
Prior to Fox, she practiced law and was a federal managing attorney and acting director at the Social Security Administration.
The Five is described as a roundtable show that debates politics, pop culture, etc.
Quote from Suzanne Scott: 'Fifteen years later, The Five remains a powerhouse...'
Quote from Compagno: 'I couldn’t be more honored to join The Five...'
Framing: Emphasizes a 'shake-up' of 'The Five', suggesting a significant change, and notes the show is 'most-watched'. — Promotional and complimentary, focusing on Compagno's achievements and the show's success, with a celebratory tone.
Facts Included:
Emily Compagno is moving to a full-time seat on 'The Five' from 'Outnumbered'.
The move is effective Sept. 8.
She will join co-hosts Greg Gutfeld, Dana Perino, and Jesse Watters, with Harold Ford Jr. and Jessica Tarlov in the liberal seat.
Compagno will leave 'Outnumbered', with a rotating personality filling in until a permanent replacement is named.
Includes direct quote from Fox News Media CEO Suzanne Scott: 'Emily is a highly accomplished...'
Includes quote from Compagno: 'Having an official seat at the table...'
The Five averaged 3.6 million viewers and 322,000 in the key 25-54 demographic in Q2.
The show has been #1 in cable news for 19 consecutive quarters.
Compagno joined Fox in 2018, became co-host of 'Outnumbered' in 2021, and wrote 'Under His Wings' (Fox News Books) which was a #1 bestseller.
Compagno's legal career included roles in criminal defense, civil litigation, and at the Social Security Administration.
She was a federal managing attorney and acting director.
She served as a judicial extern for Judge John T. Noonan on the Ninth Circuit.
Held legal positions in South Africa and Brazil.
She was captain of the Oakland Raiders' cheerleading squad and an NFL ambassador.
She holds degrees from University of Washington and University of San Francisco School of Law.
Fox News is run by Fox Corp, sister company to The Post's owner News Corp.
Framing: Headline is straightforward, focusing on the appointment itself, without extra commentary. — Analytical and slightly critical of the show's dominance; the tone is balanced but points out the business and political implications.
Facts Included:
Emily Compagno, co-host of 'Outnumbered', will join 'The Five' as co-host.
The announcement was made by Fox News CEO Suzanne Scott on Monday.
Compagno will fill the seat left by Jeanine Pirro, who left last year to serve as interim U.S. Attorney for the District of Columbia.
She will start September 8.
The Five has been the most-watched cable news show for 19 consecutive quarters.
The show was created in 2011 to give airtime to contributors.
The show's success is important for Fox News.
Quotes from Scott's statement: 'Emily is a highly accomplished host...'
Compagno's background: military family, joined Fox in 2018, works on Fox Nation, hosted a true crime podcast, criminal defense attorney, Oakland Raiders cheerleader.
Mentions the reactor pool story involving Pirro and the contract.
Each row is one claim, attributed to the outlet whose wording states it most clearly. Confidence rates how directly the source text states the claim — explicit and unhedged rates high; hedged, pieced-together, or internally inconsistent statements rate lower. It does not measure whether the claim is true. Status counts the distinct outlets we found asserting it — so a single-source claim can still show high confidence, and a multi-source claim can show medium. Every one of those outlets is named beside the status, so you can check the count against the list. For claims extracted before we began storing that list, the row says so: it names the outlet the claim is quoted from and states that we have not recorded which outlets backed it. Outlets wrote at different times, so a figure that evolves — a casualty count, for example — can legitimately differ between rows; check the "as of" time next to each claim's source.
Claim
Confidence
Status
ClaimEmily Compagno will join Fox News' The Five as a full-time co-host effective September 8.
ClaimOn The Five, Emily Compagno will join co-hosts Greg Gutfeld, Dana Perino, and Jesse Watters, with Harold Ford Jr. and Jessica Tarlov rotating in the liberal seat.
ClaimFox News Media CEO Suzanne Scott said: "Emily is a highly accomplished host whose energy and talent have made her a standout across Fox News Media, and we are thrilled to officially welcome her to the show."
ClaimEmily Compagno said: "Having an official seat at the table on what I truly believe is the most fun show on television is an incredible privilege."
ClaimEmily Compagno said she couldn't be more honored to join The Five, a team she has long admired and been fortunate to work alongside over the years, and is grateful for the opportunity.
ClaimEmily Compagno was selected as an NFL ambassador, representing the league internationally and visiting U.S. troops in Iraq and Kuwait on a USO tour.
ClaimEmily Compagno holds a bachelor's degree in political science from the University of Washington and a law degree from the University of San Francisco School of Law.
ClaimPresident Trump expressed displeasure with a decision by Jeanine Pirro to pull back on blaming vandals for damage at the Reflecting Pool on the National Mall.
ClaimTrump awarded a no-bid contract valued at $14.7 million to Atlantic Industrial Coatings to repaint and waterproof the bottom of the Reflecting Pool basin.
5 outlets · 5 articles consulted: Fox News — World, Deadline, The Hollywood Reporter, New York Post, Variety38 claims extractedVersion 3Written 2026-08-24