Lead

EasyJet has opened talks with US investment firm Castlelake, despite rejecting a fourth takeover proposal worth £4.9bn, according to a report in The Guardian. The British budget carrier unanimously rejected the latest offer of 650p a share, saying it still "substantially" undervalued the company while flagging "significant questions of deliverability." However, in a statement on Thursday, easyJet indicated a slight thawing in its position.

The airline said: "The board believes that giving Castlelake access to limited commercial information, as Castlelake sought in the letter which contained the fourth proposal, might produce a more attractive proposal that better reflects the value of easyJet and its prospects and the interests of shareholders thereto." It added: "The board continues to be concerned about the ownership structure and deliverability of any offer from Castlelake, and the time it will take."

Castlelake, which is headquartered in Minneapolis and manages $38bn (£28bn) in assets, has until 5pm on 5 July to improve its offer or walk away. EasyJet's share price was up 6% on Thursday morning at 575p, per The Guardian.

Coverage Comparison

Two Guardian reports provide the bulk of the coverage analyzed. The earlier report focuses on Castlelake's third takeover proposal, worth £4.7bn (625p a share), which was also rejected by easyJet's board. The later report covers the fourth proposal and the subsequent opening of talks. Both reports maintain a neutral tone, though the earlier one quotes Castlelake's description of easyJet's reluctance to engage, while the later one includes easyJet's characterization of the offer as undervaluing the company.

Key Claims

  • EasyJet rejected a fourth takeover offer from Castlelake worth £4.9bn, at 650p a share. (The Guardian)
  • EasyJet's board believes the offer "substantially" undervalues the company and has "significant questions of deliverability." (The Guardian)
  • Despite the rejection, easyJet has agreed to give Castlelake access to limited commercial information in hopes of receiving a higher bid. (The Guardian)
  • Castlelake has until 5pm on 5 July to improve its offer or walk away. (The Guardian, single-source)
  • EasyJet's share price rose 6% on Thursday morning to 575p following the announcement. (The Guardian)
  • Castlelake's previous offers were at 403p, 560p, and 600p per share, according to the two reports. The fourth proposal at 650p is higher than the earlier 625p offer, which easyJet described as "highly opportunistic." (The Guardian)
  • EasyJet had lost about a fifth of its value since the start of the year, as noted in the earlier coverage. The airline's share price has risen by 36% over the last month amid takeover prospects. (The Guardian, consistent across both reports)
  • Castlelake has partnered with two EU national investors to meet EU regulations requiring majority EU ownership and control of European carriers. The partners are Peter Bellew, a former Malaysia Airlines CEO and former easyJet and Ryanair executive, and Mark Breen, CEO of Dublin-based Oneiros Aerospace. (The Guardian)

Perspectives

EasyJet's Board

EasyJet's board has consistently rejected Castlelake's advances, arguing that the offers undervalue the company. While opening talks, they maintain concerns about the ownership structure, deliverability, and the time any deal would take. They hope that providing limited information may lead to a more attractive proposal.

Castlelake

Castlelake has been publicly pushing for engagement, making its third proposal public to allow shareholders to evaluate it. The firm believes its offers are credible and is working to comply with EU ownership rules by adding EU-based partners. Castlelake hopes to improve its bid after scrutinizing easyJet's books.

Market Reaction

Investors have responded positively to the prospect of a takeover, with easyJet's share price rising 36% in the past month and up 6% on the day of the announcement, suggesting the market sees value in Castlelake's interest.


This article is based on reports from The Guardian published on consecutive days. No other outlets were included in the analysis.