Lead

Brazil, sitting on the world's second-largest reserves of rare earths, is drawing global attention as Washington encourages exploration to challenge China's dominance in the market for these critical minerals. However, despite the potential, the Latin American giant currently produces only a marginal amount, exporting a mere 20 tons in 2024, according to the US Geological Survey (USGS).

Rare earths are essential components in everything from smartphones and electric vehicles to wind turbines and military equipment, making them increasingly vital in the shift toward renewable energy and advanced technologies.

Coverage Comparison

Reports from Dawn and Deutsche Welle (DW) both highlight Brazil's enormous potential but take slightly different angles. While Dawn focuses on the challenges standing in the way of Brazil's rise, DW emphasizes a new "gold rush" for rare earths, with a tone of optimism driven by surging demand.

Both sources agree that China still leads the world in both reserves and production, but Brazil's 20 million-plus tons of rare earths place it far ahead of India, the third-largest holder with an estimated 6.9 million tons.

Key Claims

  • Brazil holds the world's second-largest rare earth reserves, with estimated deposits of around 21 million tons, according to the USGS.
  • In 2024, Brazil exported only 20 tons of rare earths, while global production stood at 390,000 tons, with China accounting for approximately two-thirds of the total.
  • Demand for magnet rare earth elements has doubled since 2015 and is expected to grow another third by 2030, according to the International Energy Agency (IEA).
  • USA Rare Earths acquired Brazil's only active rare earth mine for $2.8 billion, as reported by multiple sources.
  • The Caldeira project in Minas Gerais, operated by Australian company Meteoric Resources, is claimed to be the world's largest ionic clay deposit—a claim carried by DW.
  • Washington is actively encouraging exploration in Brazil as part of its strategy to reduce dependence on China, though this claim is less widely reported.

Perspectives

The Optimistic Outlook

Companies like Meteoric Resources see Brazil as the future of rare earth production. Andrew Tunks, CEO of Meteoric, told DW, "The next big, rare earth projects in the world will be in Brazil," adding that the country will eventually compete with China. With 2,758 mining applications pending at Brazil's National Mining Agency—a sharp jump compared to just over 250 between 1975 and 2020—the sense of a rush is tangible.

The Cautious Reality

Industry experts caution that large reserves do not automatically translate to production. Rare earth elements are found mixed with dozens of other compounds and require a complex, costly separation process. Pablo Cesario, president of the Brazilian Mining Institute (IBRAM), explained that between extraction and a 99.9% pure oxide product, there are at least 400 industrial processes. He noted that while Brazil can achieve this at a laboratory scale, industrial-scale technology is scarce globally.

Julio Nery, IBRAM's director of mining affairs, added that Brazil needs infrastructure, technological research, and cheaper, more abundant energy to ramp up production. These hurdles, along with the small current output, suggest that any transformation will take time.

The United States' interest in Brazil, highlighted by Dawn, is part of a broader geopolitical push to secure supply chains. A $2.8 billion acquisition by USA Rare Earths of Brazil's only active mine signals concrete investment, but the gap between ambition and output remains wide.

As the world's demand for rare earths grows—doubling for magnet elements since 2015 and expected to rise further—Brazil's role could become critical. Yet, as reports suggest, turning geological wealth into industrial reality is a formidable challenge.