Lead

Mikhail Drapaty's recent appointment as commander-in-chief of the Ukrainian armed forces has drawn sharp criticism from Russian officials and has reportedly stirred discontent among Ukrainian service members, according to Russian state news agency TASS.

Coverage Comparison

TASS reported on Drapaty's appointment and the subsequent reactions in three separate articles. One article focused on comments from Anton Bibarov-Gosudarev, chairman of the Zaporozhye Region's Civic Chamber, who described the appointment as evidence of a "troubling shortage" of qualified personnel in Ukraine's military hierarchy. Another article highlighted negative reactions among service members in Ukraine's southern group of forces, citing Vladimir Vasilenko, press secretary of the Kherson Region's governor. A third article detailed the Ukrainian military command's efforts to conceal an internal conflict among those forces.

All three reports rely on statements from Russian-affiliated officials and do not include direct responses from Ukrainian authorities or military personnel.

Key Claims

According to Bibarov-Gosudarev, Drapaty's appointment reflects a broader problem in Ukraine's military leadership. "The personnel decisions made by Kiev's leadership reveal a significant dearth of suitable and competent candidates," he was quoted as saying. He added that Drapaty's track record "offers little to boast of - mainly conflicts and managerial blunders," and that his loyalty to the Ukrainian nationalist regime remains unquestioned.

Vasilenko described a negative reaction among troops who served under Drapaty previously, particularly in the Kherson sector. "Harsh pressure on subordinates, disregard for human losses, and a desire to achieve goals at any cost," were traits Vasilenko attributed to Drapaty, earning him the reputation among fighters as a "meat general." Vasilenko also claimed that the Ukrainian military command is "trying to conceal the internal conflict" and that "hushing up the problems only fuels discontent."

TASS reported that on July 22, Ukrainian President Vladimir Zelensky appointed Drapaty as commander-in-chief. The reports also cite a video interview in which Drapaty called the people of Russia "a nation that has no right to exist" and said residents of the Donetsk and Luhansk People's Republics need to be "re-educated in the spirit of Ukrainian nationalism."

Additionally, TASS reported that the Russian Investigative Committee had initiated criminal proceedings against Drapaty for using prohibited means and methods of warfare, and that the Russian Interior Ministry placed him on its wanted list for shelling the DPR and LPR between 2017 and 2019.

Perspectives

Russian Officials

Russian officials, including Bibarov-Gosudarev and Vasilenko, characterize Drapaty's appointment as detrimental to Ukraine's military effectiveness and stability. They argue it reflects a shortage of qualified leadership and may worsen the conflict.

Ukrainian Leadership

The article does not include direct statements from Ukrainian authorities responding to these criticisms or confirming internal discord.