Lead
The Asian Football Confederation (AFC) has voiced strong criticism over FIFA's handling of a proposal to sell a stake in the World Cup to private investors, calling the lack of consultation "totally unacceptable." After FIFA withdrew the plan, AFC President Sheikh Salman bin Ebrahim Al Khalifa welcomed the decision but stressed that future initiatives must be discussed with transparency and proper consultation.
Coverage Comparison
Al Jazeera covered the story in multiple reports, tracing the AFC's reaction from initial criticism to eventual approval of FIFA's reversal. The first report highlighted Sheikh Salman's letter to member associations in which he branded FIFA's lack of consultation as "totally unacceptable," and expressed concern that FIFA's unilateral actions undermined the foundations of continental football. A later report detailed the AFC's statement of solidarity with UEFA and CONCACAF, which had already rejected the proposal, and expressed "deep concern" over the proposed $20bn commercial subsidiary. A subsequent report noted that Sheikh Salman welcomed FIFA's decision to walk back the plans and called for transparency and consultation in the future.
The reports consistently depict a sequence of events: FIFA announced the proposal on Tuesday, regional confederations reacted with surprise and criticism, and FIFA President Gianni Infantino said the plans were scrapped after listening to the views expressed.
Key Claims
- FIFA planned to create a $20bn commercial subsidiary, named FIFA Forward Enterprise (FFE), to run the World Cup and its other events, according to Al Jazeera's reporting.
- The plan was to raise up to $4.2bn by selling about a 20 percent stake to private investors in the new unit, as stated by Al Jazeera.
- The AFC said it was not consulted by FIFA at any level prior to the public announcement of the proposal, and had not received any detailed governance, financial, or legal analysis of the proposal.
- AFC President Sheikh Salman described the lack of consultation as "totally unacceptable" in a letter to the AFC's 47 member associations, a copy of which was seen by Reuters, according to Al Jazeera.
- UEFA voted unanimously to boycott all FIFA events unless the plans were dropped, and CONCACAF also rejected the proposal, as reported by Al Jazeera.
- The AFC said it "stands in solidarity" with UEFA and CONCACAF but stopped short of threatening to boycott FIFA events.
- The AFC said the proposed subsidiary "cannot realistically achieve the necessary broad consensus and unity required to move forward."
- FIFA President Gianni Infantino said the plans had been scrapped after listening "carefully to all the views."
Perspectives
The AFC, under President Sheikh Salman, has been the most vocal critic among the confederations. In a letter to member associations, Sheikh Salman wrote: "The AFC notes with great concern and disappointment that it was not consulted by FIFA at any level prior to the public announcement of this proposal. And nor has it received any detailed governance, financial or legal analysis of the proposal and its potential repercussions, which is totally unacceptable." He also said the AFC is "deeply concerned that FIFA's unilateral actions appear to undermine the very foundations of continental football, which are based on solidarity, cooperation and transparency."
Following FIFA's reversal, Sheikh Salman expressed a more conciliatory tone, stating he expects "any initiative that has the potential to impact global football will be presented and discussed with the Confederations, the FIFA Council, Member Associations and other stakeholders in a timely, transparent and meaningful manner." He added that "the future of global football must always be shaped through proper consultation, collective dialogue and respect for the established governance structures of our game."
UEFA and CONCACAF, while not directly quoted in the reports, are reported to have rejected the proposal, with UEFA voting unanimously to boycott all FIFA events unless the plans were dropped. The AFC's statement acknowledged the possibility of a boycott entering public discourse, saying: "The fact that the situation has reached the point where the real possibility of a FIFA World Cup boycott has entered public discourse should concern everyone who cares about the future of our game. Football should never have been placed in such a position."
FIFA, through President Gianni Infantino, defended its decision to scrap the plans, saying it had listened "carefully to all the views." The reports do not include additional FIFA statements or responses beyond this.