Lead
ABC has accused the US Federal Communications Commission (FCC) of using the threat of cancelled broadcast licenses as part of an intimidation campaign against media critical of President Donald Trump. In a court filing on Thursday, the Disney-owned company highlighted the FCC's decision to conduct an early license review of eight ABC stations, arguing that the move serves as a warning to other outlets whose coverage Trump deems unfavourable.
"The retaliation against ABC is a signal to every media company in the country: accommodate the administration's view of what news coverage should look like or pay the price," ABC wrote in its filing, adding that the FCC is seeking "a media industry too fearful of official reprisal to report the news freely."
Coverage Comparison
The Guardian reported that a group of prominent former FCC officials, including key staffers and commissioners appointed by both Democratic and Republican presidents, issued a filing Tuesday warning that the agency is trying to send a "chilling message" to broadcasters. The group includes Mark S Fowler, who served as FCC chair during Ronald Reagan's presidency; Alfred C Sikes, who served as FCC chair during George HW Bush's presidency; and Thomas E Wheeler, who served as FCC chair during Barack Obama's presidency, along with several high-ranking lawyers and advisers to past commissioners.
In their filing, the coalition wrote: "This early license renewal proceeding is unprecedented in the history of the Federal Communications Commission and a grave violation of both the Communications Act and the Constitution. Through this proceeding, the FCC seeks to censor Disney's and ABC's speech and send a chilling message to all broadcasters: carry speech we don't like at your peril."
Al Jazeera's coverage focused on the broader pattern of pressure on media outlets, noting that the Trump administration has frequently sought to pressure companies over coverage critical of the president and his allies. The outlet also reported that Trump has filed a $10bn lawsuit against the BBC, and is pursuing defamation lawsuits against The New York Times and The Wall Street Journal for $15bn and $10bn, respectively.
Key Claims
- ABC has accused the FCC of using the threat of cancelled broadcast licenses as part of an intimidation campaign against media critical of President Donald Trump.
- The FCC's decision to conduct an early license review of eight ABC stations is seen as a warning to other outlets whose coverage Trump deems unfavourable.
- A group of former FCC officials filed a statement against the FCC's early license renewal proceeding for ABC, including former FCC chairs and commissioners from both Democratic and Republican administrations.
- The proceeding is unprecedented in FCC history, according to the former officials.
- The FCC received petitions to deny ABC license renewals for eight local television stations, submitted by the Media Research Center and the Center for American Rights.
- The Trump administration has frequently sought to pressure companies over coverage critical of the president, and Trump has filed lawsuits against the BBC, The New York Times, and The Wall Street Journal.
Perspectives
ABC
ABC argues that the FCC's early license review is retaliation for its coverage and a signal to all media companies to accommodate the administration's view of news coverage or face consequences.
Former FCC Officials
A group of former FCC chairs and commissioners from both parties called the proceeding unprecedented and a grave violation of the Communications Act and the Constitution, accusing the FCC of seeking to censor speech and send a chilling message to broadcasters.
FCC and Petitioners
The FCC, led by Brendan Carr, ordered the early license renewal after criticism of ABC by Donald and Melania Trump. Petitions to deny the renewals were filed by the Media Research Center and the Center for American Rights, which have accused networks of liberal bias.